Categories: Politics

‘Illegal, unconstitutional and void’: Georgia judge strikes down new election rules after legal fights

A Georgia judge struck down several rules recently passed by the State Elections Board (SEB) on Wednesday, measures that were a subject of fierce debate between Trump and Harris surrogates in the key battleground.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Thomas A. Cox ruled the new provisions “illegal, unconstitutional and void” in an opinion released Wednesday evening, according to multiple outlets.

It comes hours after he weighed two lawsuits on the rules – one led by the Georgia Democratic Party, and a second by civil rights groups which also included current and former GOP state officials.

One of the measures – a requirement for all ballots to be hand counted by three county election officials after they had been machine tabulated to ensure the totals match – has become a political lightening rod in recent weeks.

GEORGIA GOP CHAIR SHARES 2-PRONGED ELECTION STRATEGY AS TRUMP WORKS TO WIN BACK PEACH STATE

The Trump and Harris campaigns are pouring enormous resources into Georgia. (Getty Images)

That rule was temporarily blocked in a separate ruling made Tuesday night challenging the SEB’s new measures. Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney did not take issue with the rule’s intent but argued it would be untenable to implement at this late stage. 

Cox’s ruling invalidates that measure, while also invalidating a rule directing county officials to conduct a “reasonable inquiry” before certifying election results, and giving them the ability “to examine all election related documentation created during the conduct of elections.”

TRUMP VS HARRIS ROUND 2? VOTERS IN KEY GA COUNTY REVEAL IF THEY WANT SECOND DEBATE

Cox also blocked new signature and photo ID requirements for people dropping off absentee ballots for others.

The rules were passed last month in a 3-2 vote by the Republican majority on the elections board.

Democrats had accused the GOP officials of trying to sow doubt and chaos in the elections process, while supporters of the rule changes said they were necessary guardrails to ensure voter confidence.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney, pictured here, blocked one of the measures at issue in Judge Cox’s hearing after he heard a separate lawsuit Tuesday. (AP Photo/John Bazemore, File)

In the wider-ranging of the two cases on Wednesday, led by Eternal Vigilance Action, a group founded by former GOP state legislator Scot Turner, the plaintiffs argued the SEB was out of its scope of authority in levying the new rules.

“Three members of the state election board, kind of like Napoleon, they put a crown on their head and say, ‘We are the emperors of election,’” the plaintiffs’ lawyer said. “No, that is not the way our system of government works.”

GEORGIA DEMS CHAIR REVEALS MESSAGE TO UNDECIDED GOP VOTERS AS HARRIS WORKS TO BUILD BROAD BASE

But the defendants and supporting groups, including attorneys for the Georgia Republican Party, argued the state’s General Assembly gave the SEB the scope to craft such rules.

“They don’t say which one of those statutes should be found unconstitutional because, remember, to rule in favor of the plaintiffs here, you’re going to have to find that the General Assembly’s grant of authority to the agency was unconstitutional,” said a lawyer for the GOP.

President Biden won Georgia by less than 1% in 2020. (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

“They don’t say which one of the three powers we have that they violated, could be all three of them, could be one of the three. And if it’s a constitutional challenge, you can’t have something that’s that vague to bring into a court to ask you to declare it to be unconstitutional.”

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Both former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris’ campaigns have dedicated significant time and resources to Georgia, which President Biden won by less than 1% in 2020.

Harris’ campaign lauded the Tuesday ruling that blocked the hand-counting ballots rule, declaring, “Our democracy is stronger thanks to this decision.”

Fox News Digital reached out to both the Trump and Harris campaigns for comment.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Share

Recent Posts

Drone mishap during Orlando holiday aerial show sends child to hospital

close Video Several drones crash during aerial show in Orlando, Florida Video shows the moment…

2 hours ago

Hochul slammed for saying she’s made subways safer on same day woman burned alive on train

close Video Fox News Flash top headlines for December 22 Fox News Flash top headlines…

2 hours ago

Panama’s president hits back at Trump idea to reclaim key canal

Panama's president has responded to President-elect Trump's idea that his new administration could try to…

2 hours ago

Retiring GOP congresswoman’s decline has been ‘very rapid,’ son says

Rep. Kay Granger, R-Texas, experienced a "very rapid" decline since moving into a retirement facility,…

2 hours ago

TikTok divestment could be ‘deal of the century’ for Trump, House China Committee chair says

EXCLUSIVE: House China Committee Chairman John Moolenaar told Fox News Digital that President-elect Donald Trump…

2 hours ago

Violent Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua terrorizing Americans in at least 19 states

close Video Tren de Aragua suspects arrested in Bronx, New York Fox News correspondent CB…

6 hours ago